Skip to content
Ars Notoria
Ars Notoria

The Art of the Noteworthy — The London Bimestral — ISSN 2979-3378

  • Home
  • About
  • Humane Socialism
  • Contributors
  • Contact
  • Original Books
  • Checkout
0
Ars Notoria

The Art of the Noteworthy — The London Bimestral — ISSN 2979-3378

crater on the dirt ground near the destroyed houses

Western Collateral Damage in Ukraine

Ars Notoria, 28th October 202629th October 2026

Photograph by Yevhen Sukhenko


The Disastrous Defeat of a Failed Financialised Proxy

“Capitalism is the greatest creator of wolves in human history, and imperialism has not only been the greatest creator of wolves but also the greatest wolf that has ever existed.”

Fidel Castro

by Richard Steinhardt

There are two cauldrons the Russian Federation has set up to weaken the West, financial and military. The military cauldron drains NATO’s conventional artillery, air defence, and armoured stockpiles faster than the Western defence industrial base can produce. The financial cauldron systematically destroys the assets that underwrote the West’s economic investment in the Ukraine proxy.

The sudden desperation of Western deal makers and envoys like Witkoff and Kushner to force a freeze in the front lines, or a diplomatic settlement where most of Ukraine remains in the Western sphere of influence, stems from a financial crisis precipitated by the West’s military crisis. They plead for a Russian Federation halt before complete liquidation of most of the West’s assets occurs.

The downfall of this Western proxy in Eastern Europe will not come from a sudden dramatic capitulation of the Ukrainians. It will come when the private equity firms, the foreign board members, and the international debt holders look at their portfolios and projected returns and realise that the farmland, the gas fields, and the critical minerals are almost all irretrievably gone, and that all they are left holding is collateral damage.

The financialisation of Ukraine’s energy infrastructure began long before the Russian Federation incursion in February 2022. It was driven initially by IMF structural adjustment orders. The prelude and starting gun was when Ukraine lifted its ban on agricultural land sales and deregulated gas and critical mineral concessions in 2020 and 2021 respectively.

The assets making up Ukraine’s underlying economic collateral were a vast array of natural wealth, including state enterprises and financial concessions. These assets were heavily integrated into Western financial structures, and are now at risk or gone as the frontline shifts.

The Delicious Prospect of Ukrainian Agricultural Land


grayscale photo of harvester

Photograph by Alex Rusin on Pexels

Ukraine possesses roughly 33 million hectares of arable land, containing some of the most fertile Chornozem (black earth) soil on Earth. Under pressure from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank as conditions for sovereign loans, Ukraine lifted its 20-year ban on land sales in July 2021. Ukrainian domestic law, foreign asset managers, private equity funds, and agribusinesses such as Nibulon, Kernel, and Western-backed funds like NCH Capital, gained control over millions of hectares through long-term corporate leases, shareholding in Ukrainian holding companies, and debt financing. In practice, agricultural production and grain export terminals in Odessa and Mykolaiv served as the primary collateral for Ukraine’s external debt servicing to the IMF and European lenders. Odessa is now blockaded and under fire.

The Tasty Prospect of Critical Ukrainian Minerals and Hydrocarbons


vast salt mine under blue sky

Photograph by Mr Dr3igeteilt on Pexels

Ukraine also has on an estimated $12 trillion to $26 trillion in unmined mineral deposits, making it one of the most resource rich regions in Europe. Ukraine holds significant European reserves of lithium, essential for EV batteries and energy storage, titanium (which is crucial for aerospace and defence manufacturing) and rare-earth elements. The vast majority of these key lithium fields, such as the Shevchenkivske deposit in the Donetsk region and titanium deposits are located in eastern and southern Ukraine, areas now either behind Russian lines or on the current frontline.

Over 80% of Ukraine’s proven oil reserves and 90% of its natural gas production sit within the Dnieper-Donetsk basin in eastern Ukraine. Controlling these assets was seen as key to transforming Ukraine into a major natural gas exporter to Western Europe, offsetting European reliance on Russian state energy giants like Gazprom. Independent producers like Burisma Holdings held dozens of extraction licences across the hydrocarbon-rich Dnieper-Donetsk basin. The appointment of foreign elites, including the notorious Hunter Biden, former Polish President Aleksander Kwasniewski, and former CIA counterterrorism officials, to the boards of Ukrainian energy companies like Burisma was designed to shield these private firms from local corruption probes while signalling Western political alignment. By placing Western political figures on company boards, these domestic energy assets were effectively institutionalised and tied into Western investment networks, allowing regional gas rights to be floated on international markets.

Severe Emerging Western Corporate Vulnerability


husky siberiano fotos en estudio

Capitalism, the greatest wolf that has ever existed. Photograph by Ivan Garfias on Pexels

Corporate entities, foreign board directors, and major asset managers like BlackRock and JPMorgan packaged projected physical assets into Eurobonds, loan backstops, and private equity ‘vehicles’. Western capital fantasised about future high-yield returns, backed by forward projecting US military power, while Ukrainian elites were promised a strong security umbrella. But once a lithium field or agricultural enclave falls under Russian control or is rendered inaccessible by unexploded bombs or shells the asset manager must mark the value of assets down to zero. The private equity thesis, promoted by major international financial institutions, collapses into speculative rubbish.

BlackRock stands out as one of the largest private holders of Ukraine’s sovereign international bonds, a position whose value erodes as territorial loss shrinks Ukraine’s GDP base. When institutional investors recognise that Western military power cannot secure their capital, they refuse to roll over debt or supply fresh investment. The burden of sustaining the state budget shifts entirely from “private-public reconstruction partnerships” back onto public tax revenues in London, Brussels, and Washington. In other words, the risky investments are financed by the ordinary European tax payers.

In agriculture, one of the earliest and largest American private equity investors in post-Soviet land manages AgroProsperis, which leases and farms over 400,000 hectares of Ukrainian land. Alongside it, Kernel Holding S.A., MHP and Nibulon, backed heavily by Western capital including the EBRD, IFC, Vanguard, and European private equity, hold millions of hectares of long-term leases on Chornozem/Black Earth, processing plants, and deep-water grain terminals, around blockaded Odessa and Mykolaiv.

Major grain traders Cargill, ADM and Bunge operate massive export terminals, grain silos, and oilseed processing plants across Ukraine; Cargill owns a 51% stake in the Neptune deep-water grain terminal at the port of Pivdennyi. With Russian Federation attacks and advances there is a loss of port terminals and processing hubs, capital-intensive Black Sea facilities that are now target zones are annexed, or cut off from international shipping routes while decades of supply-chain integration bringing Ukrainian wheat, corn and sunflower oil directly into European and global markets is completely destroyed.

European and American critical mineral ventures are in danger. Agreements signed under the 2021 EU-Ukraine Strategic Partnership on Raw Materials and U.S. bilateral resource frameworks target Ukraine’s lithium, titanium, beryllium, and rare earths are now gone up in smoke. The Shevchenkivske lithium deposit in the Donetsk Region, one of Europe’s largest lithium reserves, intended to supply Western EV battery supply chains, is effectively lost, along with the Krutaya Balka Lithium Field in the Zaporizhzhia region and titanium extraction in the Zhitomir and Dnipropetrovsk regions.

Ukrainian Oligarchs Acted as Agents of US Imperialism

Ukraine’s elite played an active, indispensable role in converting state assets into private commodities and anchoring them to Western corporate capital. The role of domestic comprador Ukrainian politicians and oligarchs is central to understanding how the country’s assets were packaged, financialised, and put at risk. Western investors were promised high-yield returns on Ukraine’s rich resources, while Ukrainian politicians were promised that mortgaging the country’s wealth would guarantee an ironclad Western military shield.

Ukraine’s economic architecture since 1991 has been governed by an “Oligarchic-Political Complex.” The primary goal of these elites was to acquire formerly state-owned assets at post-Soviet fire-sale prices, offshore their profits, and seek Western legal and corporate protection against internal rivals or Russian buyouts.

The domestic Ukrainian elites operated under a calculation: they believed that by selling, leasing, or mortgaging their nation’s physical wealth to Western capital, they were securing an absolute security guarantee. Post 2014 Ukrainian politicians believed that if BlackRock, American agribusinesses, and European energy firms owned the financial rights to Ukrainian soil and minerals, the West would be forced to deploy whatever military power was necessary to defend them. Instead of securing their assets, the Ukrainian elite have facilitated the creation of a massive, uncollateralised risk pool. The financial cauldron is now degrading the West’s global corporate capitalist system.

Rinat Akhmetov, Ukraine’s richest industrialist, made System Capital Management and DTEK into a conglomerate, dominating the nation’s coal, steel and thermal energy grid in Donbas. Now under Russian Federation control. He used his local political dominance to secure massive state energy concessions and issued Eurobonds in London to fund DTEK, effectively linking Western creditors directly to the Ukrainian frontline: when those industrial hubs were physically devastated or annexed, his corporate empire collapsed, destroying both his personal net worth and the collateral backing his Eurobonds.

Agribusiness titans Andriy Verevskyi (Kernel) and Oleg Bakhmatyuk (UkrLandFarming) similarly used political influence in the Verkhovna Rada to build vast empires, exploiting long-term lease loopholes long before land sales were legalised to aggregate millions of hectares of Chornozem into single corporate holdings. To fund operations they sold equity stakes and took on billions in debt from Western asset managers such as NCH Capital and European development banks; when war engulfed eastern and southern Ukraine, the leased land became unusable, leaving Western creditors holding equity in ruined soil.

Mykola Zlochevsky, Minister of Ecology and Natural Resources under Viktor Yanukovych, used his cabinet position to grant his own company, Burisma, dozens of lucrative oil and gas extraction licences across the Dnieper-Donetsk basin, then institutionalised Burisma’s board with high-profile Western figures, most famously Hunter Biden and former Polish President Aleksander Kwasniewski, to protect those concessions from domestic prosecution and rivals, monetising Ukrainian state gas fields by tying them to Western political protection.

The conversion of Ukraine’s national wealth into foreign-backed collateral required direct legislative action by successive Ukrainian governments from the 2014 putsch onwards, forming an elite financialisation cycle. Ukrainian politicians passed land reform and deregulation laws, oligarchic alliances consolidated leases and natural gas licences, Western capital flowed in through Eurobonds and equity funds, and physical territorial loss then seized or ruined the assets, breaking the financial loop.

Petro Poroshenko King Chocolate (President 2014-2019) headed the structural reforms demanded by the IMF and Western institutions after Euromaidan, privatising state enterprises and reforming energy tariffs to lay the basis for foreign integration into Ukraine’s municipal and industrial sectors.

Volodymyr Zelensky continued this trajectory under intense pressure from international lenders. In 2020 his government passed the laws, mentioned earlier, lifting Ukraine’s twenty-year ban on agricultural land sales effective July 2021. His administration also took assets away from oligarchs. They were framed as anti-corruption, but what these laws actually did was strip domestic oligarchs media holdings and allow multinational corporate capital and Western asset management firms take over. The precise definition of a comprador.

Ukrainian Debt Service is Collapsing


aerial view of industrial open pit mining site

Photograph by Xiang Qi on Pexels

In energy and hydrocarbons, Burisma Holdings, a privately held Ukrainian extraction company infamous for placing Western political elites, including the notorious Hunter Biden, on its board to reinforce its corporate footprint will lose dozens of licences across the Dnieper-Donetsk Basin, which holds over 80% of Ukraine’s gas reserves. DTEK, owned by Rinat Akhmetov and backed by Western bondholders, is Ukraine’s largest private energy investor, controlling thermal power plants, renewables, and coal mines; most of its traditional coal assets sit in the Donbas, and its thermal and green power plants face systemic physical destruction. The result is a debt service collapse: hundreds of millions of dollars in Western-issued Eurobonds backed by domestic energy tariffs that can no longer be collected from a bankrupt domestic market.

Western Collateral in Ukraine is Vanishing

As public funds are continuously transferred to meet uncollateralised guarantees and absorb non-performing proxy loans, internal political stability in Western nations breaks down. Citizens in Western Europe and North America observe domestic infrastructure decaying while billions in taxpayer capital are liquidated to settle the bad bets of asset managers and political elites. demonstrations against cuts to services and underinvestment have broken out all over Europe.

As Russia advances or takes over territory, these physical assets are removed from the Western balance sheet and the potential revenue streams backing Western capital or future debt repayment are permanently lost to the West. Each kilometre captured reduces the economic viability of the remaining Ukrainian rump state, increasing the financial burden on European and American taxpayers who must fund both military aid and state budget deficits.

When physical control over these assets is lost, the financial architecture behind them breaks down. Russia now controls between up to 100% of Ukraine’s critical lithium and rare-earth deposits, along with key industrial ports and agricultural zones. The long-term leases, equity funds, and debt instruments tied to those specific fields, mines, and infrastructure projects lose their underlying value. Western asset managers and sovereign lenders cannot collect returns or enforce claims on assets located in territories annexed. What was meant to be a profitable, asset-backed integration of Ukrainian resources into Western markets turns into a massive, uncollateralised liability that must be continuously absorbed by foreign taxpayers.

Russia’s primary strategic goal is the roll-back of NATO infrastructure and foreign military-economic footholds on its border. But neither will the Russian Federation accept a peace deal that codifies legal U.S. corporate ownership over central and western Ukraine, and in the end, Ukrainian society will not accept sacrificing hundreds of thousands more lives only to become a privatised corporate ward of foreign private equity firms. Any sovereign post-war government in Kyiv will eventually be forced to emulate the Russian template: prying loose foreign profiteers and re-nationalising energy, land, and minerals to rebuild the state.

Note that, neither a victorious Russia nor an exhausted post-war Ukraine in reconstruction will ever permit Western Europe to rearm in future. The USA is out of their reach. Having severed their own cheap energy supply chains and exhausted their military inventories, Britain, France, and Germany and the other European countries lack the capacity to build a sovereign war economy. Western European elites are weak, deindustrialised, and financially insolvent, staring directly down the barrels of Russian hard-power deterrence.

Parallels between Ukraine and Russia in the 1990s


A middle-aged man with silver hair and a serious expression, wearing a black suit and patterned tie, stands against a blurred background.

Boris Yeltsin. Photograph courtesy of the Duma

The parallels between the financialisation of Ukraine’s sovereign wealth over the last decade and the Yeltsin years (1991-1999) in Russia are profound, and striking. In the 90s, through schemes like Loans-for-Shares, Russian state sovereignty was liquidated into private hands. Foreign technocrats and domestic oligarchs acquired crown-jewel assets for pennies while public infrastructure collapsed.

Both models, Russia’s and Ukraine’s, extracted private profits while concentrating systemic liabilities and social decay onto the general population. In the Yeltsin era, as natural resources and industrial monopolies were privatised, hyperinflation and capital flight decimated ordinary Russians’ savings; by August 1998 the Russian state suffered total fiscal collapse, defaulting on domestic GKO bonds and devaluing the rouble, while oligarchs banked their fortunes offshore in London, Cyprus, and Zurich. Under the Ukraine Model, as industrial heartlands in the east were engulfed in conflict and key assets lost, the sovereign debt burden concentrated onto a shrinking population and Zeklensky’s rump state, and basic state functions were rendered entirely dependent on continuous emergency bailouts and debt service transfers from Western backers.

In both instances, ruling domestic elites believed that financialising their state’s wealth and aligning with Western capital would grant them permanent regime security, a false security guarantee loop in which selling or mortgaging state resources to the West and securitising assets with Wall Street and oligarchs was expected to produce a geopolitical shield, but instead produced physical asset loss and financial collapse. Yeltsin’s inner circle (“The Family”) believed that integrating Russia into global capital markets and empowering pro-Western oligarchs would make the West treat Russia as an equal partner and back Yeltsin’s political survival unconditionally; instead, Russia suffered economic devastation, regional destabilisation, and NATO expansion right up to its borders. Likewise, Ukrainian politicians and oligarchs believed that if BlackRock, American agribusinesses, and Western energy firms held financial contracts over Ukrainian farmland, gas fields, and lithium deposits, the West would deploy whatever military force was necessary to defend that physical perimeter.

The Future Backlash against Compradors in Ukraine


The main facade of a large orange building with multiple windows, featuring a clock at the top and surrounded by greenery and vehicles.

Lubyanka, the former headquarters of the KGB. Photograph by A.Savin

The rise of Vladimir Putin and the siloviki (people of force) in 1999-2000 was a structural revolution. The security state re-nationalised strategic assets, subordinated the oligarchs, and prioritised hard-power military and industrial sovereignty over Western integration. Vladimir Putin’s rise was built on an explicit mandate: re-nationalise state assets, rein in or jail the 1990s oligarchs, and restore state power through economic sovereignty and viability and rearmament. Vladimir Putin’s early message to the 1990s magnates (the arrest of Mikhail Khodorkovsky and the dismantling of Yukos) was simple: You can keep your money, but the state owns the politics, and the state owns the strategic core of the country’s resources.

For the siloviki, privatisation in the 90s was viewed not as “economic reform,” but as a temporary, hostile occupation by domestic bandits and foreign capital. Their long-term goal was to build a strong centralised state capable of projecting hard power, defying Western hegemony, and reclaiming economic depth.

In the 1990s and 2000s, Ukrainian and Russian security services shared intelligence, conducted joint exercises, and frequently exchanged personnel. The early Ukrainian SBU was heavily staffed by veteran Soviet officers whose loyalties were divided between Kyiv, Moscow, and their own private wealth.

When Ukrainians look at Ukraine over the last decade, with its IMF-mandated land reforms, Western corporate board seats, and financialised asset structures, they see a carbon copy of the Yeltsin 1990s. While Western observers often treat Ukraine and Russia as diametrically opposed political systems, their security architectures stemmed from the exact same institutional parentage: the Soviet KGB, the Red Army General Staff, and the Ministry of Internal Affairs.

Ukraine’s security services shared the exact same Soviet parentage as their Russian Federation equivalents, though following the post-2014 purges and the current war of attrition, the extremist nationalists took over. After the 2014 Euromaidan revolution, the Ukrainian security apparatus underwent a radical, violent purge. High-ranking SBU and military officers deemed loyal to Russia or Yanukovych fled to Moscow or were stripped of rank where they wait in the wings. The SBU and GUR were restructured under CIA and MI6 training, technological integration and control.

Ukrainian security elite shifted toward an ultra-nationalist security posture. They aligned with Western intelligence while expanding their own domestic leverage over politicians, media, and business. However, there is a huge group of Ukrainian siloviki in waiting in the Donbass and the Russian Federation willing to return and take up the reins of power.

If Ukraine emerges from the conflict broken, economically devastated, and stripped of its resource-rich territories, the civilian political class will be completely discredited, just as Yeltsin’s political class was in 1990s Russia and the only institutional force left standing in the ruins with authority, discipline, weapons, and control of the state apparatus will be the Ukrainian siloviki. The Ukrainian security elite will inevitably step in to rule the post-war state, operating on the exact same institutional logic as Moscow. But with Russian future denazification of the Ukraine inevitable, those particular ultranationalist CIA/MI6 trained siloviki will no longer be allowed to participate in reconstruction and governance.

When combined with the 5 million people living in the Donbas, Crimea, and occupied southern territories of Zaporizhzhia and Kherson, the total Ukrainian population living within the Russian sphere of influence is huge. Indeed, many of the 6 million who fled to western Europe were Russian speaking and against the war. It will be from among these people and from Ukrainian partisans who fought against the Banderite regime that the new government will be formed.

There Will Be No Last Minute Rescue for NATO

Obviously, now there will be no ‘Russian Windfall’ from regime change in the Russian Federation and soon Ukrainian collateral will be worthless to the ruling elites of the West. The Russian Federation will ignore European demands to ‘freeze the front line’. The Final Leverage of the West is the threat of broader NATO involvement or nuclear escalation; the only remaining card to attempt to compel Moscow to pause its war of attrition, allowing Western financial institutions time to offload bad debt, bail out asset managers, and write down lost collateral. Having gambled on the financialisation of Ukraine and the economic collapse of Russia, they find themselves with depleted military stockpiles, a ruined proxy balance sheet, and a consolidated Eurasian bloc. The frantic diplomatic manoeuvring by real estate negotiators and the brandishing of nuclear threats are the desperate acts of a financialised elite trying to rescue their bottom lines from the physical realities of the battlefield. Three noisy Trident submarines slip out of UK docks.

In the end the USA will retreat to the Western hemisphere, and NATO and Europe will retreat from Eastern Europe. This will mark the formal end of the transition from an era where corporate capitalism in the metropolis of the USA could financialise sovereign countries under the cover of NATO expansion.

The CIA and US intelligence apparatus attempt to continue their covert war against the Russian Federation in a demonstration of the sunk cost fallacy, despite everything. Now Europe is left alone, delegated with the task of facing down the Russian Federation and confronting it head on. NATO and Europe negotiates with a powerful, entirely remilitarised, sovereign country, backed by the economic might of China. The Russian Federation has a double-barrelled shotgun levelled point blank at our European heads. Its finger index finger rests on a light trigger.


Richard Steinhardt is a committed socialist and a radical humanist and has published in the Morning Star and a variety of other communist and socialist publications. He believes that human conscience and understanding should always precede dogma and deterministic formulas posturing as ‘social science’.

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • More
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Share on Threads (Opens in new window) Threads
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading…

Related


Discover more from Ars Notoria

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Post navigation

Previous post
Next post

Related Posts

Americanization

IRRITATING AMERICAN SPELL CHECKERS

17th October 2025

Was Noah Webster right to ‘rationalise’ the spelling of English? by Phil Hall “Now is the time and this the country in which we may expect success in attempting changes to language, science, and government. Let us then seize the present moment and establish a national language as well as…

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • More
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Share on Threads (Opens in new window) Threads
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading…
Read More
Feminism

WAKE UP WOMEN OF INDIA!

17th October 20254th March 2026

We must become self-reliant by Tasneem Sheikh Wake up! Wake up! I hear my aunt wake my sisters, cousins and me early in the morning. We were teenage girls on a vacation, staying at a distant relative’s house. The host thought it was a great time to throw a huge…

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • More
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Share on Threads (Opens in new window) Threads
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading…
Read More
Politics

DIMITRIS P. KRANIOTIS: Small Arc

11th June 20263rd July 2026

Mount Kissavos viewed from Pineios bridge in Larissa. Photograph Konstantinos Agiannis Dimitris P. Kraniotis was born in 1966 and grew up in Stomio, Larissa, Greece where Hippocrates himself spent his later years living and practicing medicine. Dimitris followed in the footsteps of Hippocrates. After studying Medicine at the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, he…

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • More
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Share on Threads (Opens in new window) Threads
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading…
Read More
©2026 Ars Notoria | WordPress Theme by SuperbThemes

Loading Comments...

You must be logged in to post a comment.

%d